Michigan appeals court sides with vape shop, against flavored vaping ban
Flavored vaping products were marketed to entice young vapers into addictive habits, the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services had argued in declaring a public health emergency last year. (Bridge photo by Robin Erb)
By Robin Erb (Bridge)
A court ruling Thursday has cast into further doubt Michigan’s 2019 emergency rules against flavored vaping products.
A three-judge panel of the Michigan Court of Appeals upheld a Court of Claims preliminary injunction against Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s September public emergency that banned flavored vaping products — products that Whitmer and the state’s health department argued lured young people into unhealthy, addictive habits.
The appeals court’s unanimous decision means the state’s emergency order remains unenforceable, for now, as litigation over its validity proceeds. Whether the state will press ahead in the courts to enforce the ban is unclear. The Michigan Department of Health and Human Services deferred questions from Bridge Magazine to the Michigan Attorney General’s office.
The Attorney General’s office did not immediately respond to requests for comment Thursday.
In a harshly worded, 13-page concurring opinion attached to the ruling, Judge Mark Boonstra called Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s order “government overreach” and found a way to lodge criticism of the governor’s response to the coronavirus outbreak, which was not a part of the vaping litigation.
Boonstra, appointed by Republican Gov. Rick Snyder, said he was writing separately “because sometimes we as Americans need a wake-up call.”
Boonstra tied the vaping ban to the Democrat governor’s executive orders during this year’s COVID-19 pandemic, writing “you might ask, what does COVID have to do with vaping? Well, maybe nothing. Our Governor has herself linked the two, however.”
“Liberty” is similarly threatened by a pandemic lockdown and the vaping products ban, Boonstra wrote: “As the adage goes, ‘give them an inch and they’ll take a mile.’ Amid the COVID-19 pandemic, that adage has new meaning. It even applies to vaping.”
In September — as the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported a rash of vaping-related illnesses — Whitmer proposed banning flavoring in e-cigarettes and other vaping devices in the state. (Public health officials ultimately linked those illnesses, including some deadly cases, to a Vitamin E acetate additive.)
Whitmer’s public health emergency order made Michigan the first state in the nation to ban flavored nicotine vaping products. Other states in the following weeks did the same.
At his Upper Peninsula vape shop in Houghton, Marc Slis, a plaintiff in the lawsuit, said Thursday he was relieved by the ruling.
The owner of 906 Vapor became the face of businesses who pushed back against the September public health order. He and others argued that they would lose their shops as consumers turned to online sales. Further, the ban — he argued — backfired as a public health effort because it would drive adult vaping consumers back to combustible tobacco, such as cigarettes.
Slis had resumed selling his products after Court of Claims Judge Cynthia Diane Stephens granted a preliminary injunction in November against the state ban.
While Whitmer’s order may never take effect, it appears to have contributed to extraordinary restrictions on the vaping industry.
Facing mounting public pressure, the major producer of flavored vaping products, JUUL, announced in October it would stop selling flavored vaping products. Several states passed laws restricting flavored tobacco sales and federal law signed by President Trump in the closing days of 2019 bans sales of nicotine vaping products to anyone under 21.
In Houghton, Slis has been selling products curbside only because of the COVID-19 pandemic. On Thursday, he was erecting polyacrylic sneeze shields to reopen for in-store foot traffic this holiday weekend.
“I’m extremely tired from this past 9 months,” he said. “This issue and this ruling was never far from my mind. It was my livelihood and the lives of my customers.”
You must be logged in to post a comment Login