Marsha Chartrand

Michigan has far more power outages this week than other Midwest states

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

DTE and Consumers Energy blamed the lingering outages on tough weather conditions, thick ice, trees near power lines and other challenges. (Bridge photo by Paula Gardner)

by Janelle D. James (Bridge Michigan)

Two days after a rare ice storm barreled through the Upper Midwest, power outages continued to be a far bigger challenge for Michigan than for any of its neighbors.

And it’s not even close.

More than 700,000 Michigan homes lost power following the mid-week storm, and that number had barely declined by Friday afternoon, to about 680,000, according to Power Outage U.S. which analyzes national utility data.

By comparison, Illinois had about 12,000 customer outages Friday afternoon. Wisconsin, Indiana, and Ohio combined had fewer than 3,000 outages. And Minnesota, which also received up to 21 inches of snow during the storm, had a grand total of nine household outages Friday, according to the data.

The storm closed schools, canceled flights, and caused slippery conditions throughout the Upper Midwest. Michigan’s two largest utilities blamed thick ice, trees, and large population centers for the heavy power loss.

“The number one cause of outages in Michigan is trees coming into contact with our lines,” said Josh Paciorek, a spokesperson for Consumers Energy. Consumers Energy reported 237,000 homes still without power and 8,000 downed lines on Friday, most in the southern and western part of the state. The company said it hopes that power is restored by Sunday evening but expected crews to still be working to restore power on Monday, Feb. 27.

“The 2023 ice storm blanketed southern counties in Michigan with a half inch of ice,” Paciorek said. “That ice is heavy, increasing the weight on tree branches by 30 times and adding about 500 lbs (equivalent to the weight of a baby grand piano) to the power lines.”

Nearly 460,000 DTE customers were still without power as of Friday afternoon, Feb. 24. The company predicted 90% of customers would have power restored by Friday evening and 98% of customers would have their power restored Sunday evening. Downed power lines also would be restored by Friday evening.

“We have a very populated service territory,” said Dana Blankenship, senior communication strategist at DTE. “A lot of people live in southeast Michigan, so there are a lot of homes and a lot of lines to take care of.”

According to the U.S. Census, more than 4 million people live in southeast Michigan; many of them covered by DTE, whose territory spans from Lake Michigan to Lake Erie.

Early Friday, Matt Paul, a DTE executive vice president of distribution operations, described the storm in historic terms.

“​We saw ice amounts up to three-quarters of an inch throughout southeast Michigan and that’s a level we haven’t seen in nearly 50 years,” Paul said at a press briefing.

Climate change has also played a role in more outages attributed to extreme weather in recent years. Climate Central, a nonprofit news organization, issued a report in September noting that Michigan has compiled the highest number of power outages relating to weather of any state in the nation, after Texas.

“Over the past several years,” said Paciorek of DTE, “we have seen severe storms becoming more frequent, with more and more weather events featuring severe and damaging wind gusts as storms move into the state off of Lake Michigan.”

The timing of the outages is not ideal for DTE, which is asking the Michigan Public Service Commission for a rate increase just months after receiving its last one, according to our reporting partners at BridgeDetroit.

Consumers Energy said it has over 500 crews along with help from states like Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, and Virginia assisting Michigan residents in the restoration efforts.

Since outages began Tuesday evening, Consumers said the company had restored power for 90,000 customers as of Friday, 2/24.

For as little as $1 a month, you can keep Manchester-focused news coverage alive.
Become a patron at Patreon!

Become a Monthly Patron!

You must be logged in to post a comment Login