Sara Swanson

DNR weighs in on proposed gravel mine adjacent to Watkins Lake State Park

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

by Sara Swanson

Irish Hills Concerned Citizens (IHCC), a nonprofit grassroots group organized last January to oppose a proposed gravel mine that would border Watkins Lake State Park and County Preserve, reported last week that the director of the Michigan Department of Natural Resources, Scott Bowen, has submitted a letter Norvell Township Board of Trustees expressing concerns with the impacts such a mining operation would have on the park: its waters, wetlands, birds and other wildlife, and park users if it were to go ahead.

The proposed 625-acre heavy industrial aggregate sand and gravel mine sits directly on the border of Watkins Lake State Park and County Preserve, a designated Michigan Department of Natural Resources (DNR) Waterfowl Refuge. The mining company has stated that the mine would generate 18 travel trucks an hour, 10+ hours a day for 20 years. The proposed haul route runs through a second state park in our area, Hayes State Park, as well as residential areas.

The letter states, ” We are deeply concerned that the proposed mine would impair the natural resources of the park through changing and diminishing the pattern of ground and surface water flow and the water quality of that flow, all of which is vital to sustain the park’s natural resources. We are also highly concerned that the mine would harm birds and wildlife and diminish park use and visitation with trucking, dust, noise, visual impairments and other impacts.”

It continues, “We ask Norvell Township to consider these expected negative impacts to Watkins Lake State Park and County Preserve as you determine whether to grant or deny the aggregate mining permit.”

Read the letter in full at https://ihccinfo.org/, scroll down and click on “PRESS RELEASE: Michigan DNR Director Raises Serious Concerns About Proposed Mine Next to Watkins Lake State Park”.

Under township ordinance and state law, a mining permit may only be denied under fairly narrow circumstances, one being if it would cause “very serious consequences,” including impacts on natural resources, public safety, and the overall public interest. The IHCC board has been focusing heavily on the state’s legal standard of ‘very serious consequences’ as the avenue for the Township to deny the permit.

Andy Buchsbaum, Vice President of IHCC stated, “The DNR has confirmed that the proposed mine would cause substantial harm to the adjacent state park,” that’s a very serious consequence and, under the law, any permit for a mine in this location should be denied.”

Norvell Township will discuss the letter from the DNR at its upcoming Township Board meeting tonight, Monday, November 16 at 6pm at 300 Mill Road in Norvell as it has been placed on the agenda.

The township has been in a holding pattern as American Aggregates of Michigan (AAOM), the mining company, prepares to resubmit its comprehensive zoning and site application to the township, something which was expected to happen earlier this fall.

Become a Monthly Patron!

You must be logged in to post a comment Login